OSUN RIVER SAFETY CLAIM: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT ON THE TIMELINE
23rd December 2025
Urban Alert has noted recent media coverage by PUNCH Newspapers of 19 December 2025, quoting Prof. Nusrah Afolabi-Balogun of the Fountain University, Osogbo, as stating that water from the Osun-Osogbo grove is safe for human consumption.
Following a review of the publication, the Professor’s inaugural lecture, and a subsequent clarification provided directly by Professor Afolabi-Balogun, Urban Alert considers it necessary, in the interest of public health, scientific accuracy, and responsible public communication, to clearly set the record straight.
- Clarifying the origin of the “safe for human consumption” claim
Urban Alert acknowledges and emphasises that the assertion that Osun River water is safe for human consumption did not originate from Professor Afolabi-Balogun’s research. Instead, it arose from media interpretation that significantly extended beyond the scientific scope of her work.
Professor Afolabi-Balogun has clarified that her research did not assess potable water safety, nor did it evaluate drinking-water thresholds for heavy metals or toxic contaminants. Any public framing of her work as a declaration of present-day drinking water safety is therefore inaccurate and unintended.
- Scope and timeframe of the Professor’s research
The research referenced in Professor Afolabi-Balogun’s inaugural lecture was conducted between 2016 and 2019 and focused on:
- Ecological and microbial characteristics of the Osun-Osogbo grove environment
- Biochemical properties of environmental samples during that period
- The bioremediation potential of certain microorganisms under specific conditions
Importantly, the study was ecological and biochemical in nature, rather than a regulatory or public health assessment of water quality. The Professor also explicitly noted in her conclusions that her findings do not support therapeutic claims nor serve as evidence of safety for direct human consumption; instead, they provide insight into the chemistry and biological dynamics of the river system at the time of study.
- Why bioremediation potential is not equivalent to potable water safety
While the capacity of certain organisms to transform or reduce pollutants is scientifically significant, this should not be interpreted as an assurance that untreated river water is safe to drink, particularly in the context of changing environmental pressures.
In public health terms, claims of drinking water safety must be grounded in current, time-specific testing, measurable contaminant concentrations, and comparison with recognised safety standards. Studies conducted within a defined historical period must be interpreted within that timeframe and not extended as enduring guarantees under evolving environmental conditions.
- Mining activity, documented downstream impacts, and Urban Alert’s advocacy
Urban Alert’s concern arises from persistent signals and reports from community stakeholders indicating significant environmental changes along the Osun River after 2019, attributed to intensified mining activities, particularly the widespread colour change and associated contamination risks. These reports motivated Urban Alert’s structured evidence gathering, which included physicochemical and microbial tests, and took water samples from five points (before, within, and outside the Osun-Osogbo grove). The findings of these tests reported the presence of multiple harmful indicators, including mercury, lead, and cyanide, at concentrations exceeding recognised safety thresholds and warranting urgent attention and action.
Other independent studies, including journalistic investigations drawing on scientific analyses, have documented the post-2019 deterioration and linked concerns to mining activity. Notable among these are The Cable’s 2022 investigation, which reported other scientific findings, and Al Jazeera’s report, which documented pollution concerns tied to mining.
As a data-driven organisation, Urban Alert maintains that post-2019 pollution drivers and conditions must be assessed using post-2019 data, and that earlier ecological studies, while valuable, cannot substitute for updated risk evaluations under materially altered circumstances.
- Call for updated, transparent, and independent testing
Urban Alert holds academic research in high esteem and values the relationship built with researchers and journalists over the years. We welcome the clarification provided by Professor Afolabi-Balogun, which strengthens scientific integrity rather than weakens it.
We reiterate our call for an updated, independently supervised, multi-stakeholder water quality assessment of the Osun River system, including:
- Multi-season and repeated sampling
- Clearly defined sampling points across the river system
- Multi-laboratory verification
- Transparent disclosure of methods, QA/QC protocols, and datasets
- Clear public communication distinguishing cultural, spiritual, and ecological value from ingestion risk
- Public advisory: protect health while authorities act
Pending such updated and transparent assessments, Urban Alert advises residents, visitors, and devotees to exercise caution regarding the use of untreated river water for drinking and to rely on verified safe sources where available. This advisory is issued solely as a public health safeguard and not as a dismissal of cultural or spiritual practices associated with the Osun River.
- Our message to government and regulators
Urban Alert urges relevant state and federal authorities and environmental regulators, in collaboration with local communities and researchers, to:
- Strengthen enforcement against illegal and harmful mining discharge
- Publish an actionable remediation plan with timelines, budgets, and responsible agencies
- Sustain transparent monitoring and public reporting
Conclusion
Urban Alert commends Professor Nusrah Afolabi-Balogun for her scholarly contributions and appreciates her clarification, which confirms that claims of present-day drinking water safety were not within the scope of her research. We emphasise that accurate scientific representation is crucial for informed public discourse and effective environmental protection.
Urban Alert remains committed to evidence-based advocacy, constructive engagement with researchers, and collaborative efforts to safeguard the Osun River, the Osun-Osogbo Sacred Grove, and the health of communities along this vital river system.
